Skip to content

The Right of a Minority Shareholder in an LLC to Receive Dividends and the Mechanisms for Its Legal Protection

Published ·

The Right of a Minority Shareholder in an LLC to Receive Dividends and the Mechanisms for Its Legal Protection

One of the significant sources of conflicts of interest among the shareholders of a limited liability company (LLC) is the distribution of profits generated by the company.

Such conflicts become particularly problematic when a company has successfully conducted business and consistently generated profits for many years, yet the majority shareholders refuse to distribute dividends, preferring instead to retain all accumulated profits within the company.

On the one hand, such a decision may be justified by the company's economic interests, development needs and the preservation of financial stability. On the other hand, it may substantially restrict the property interests of a minority shareholder and effectively deprive that shareholder of the opportunity to obtain economic benefits from participation in the company.

A dividend represents the portion of a company's profits distributed among its shareholders pursuant to a relevant decision. Accordingly, the right to receive dividends is closely connected to a shareholder's property rights and constitutes one of the principal economic objectives of participation in a commercial company.

It is essential, however, to distinguish between the general right to receive dividends and the right to claim a specific dividend payment.

Upon acquiring a shareholding in a company, a shareholder obtains a general right to receive dividends. Nevertheless, this does not automatically entitle the shareholder to demand a proportionate distribution of any profits generated by the company.

Under Article 145 of the Law of Georgia on Entrepreneurs, the management body of an LLC prepares a proposal for the distribution of dividends, taking into account the company's financial statements, and submits that proposal to the shareholders.

The management body must also provide a solvency statement confirming that, following the proposed dividend distribution, the company will remain capable of meeting its obligations as they fall due during the following calendar year.

The final decision on dividend distribution rests with the shareholders. It is only after such a decision has been adopted that a shareholder acquires an enforceable claim to a specific dividend payment.

Consequently, the existence of profits and the adoption of a dividend distribution resolution are separate, although interconnected, prerequisites.

This legal framework seeks to balance two competing interests: the shareholder's right to benefit economically from the company's activities and the company's interest in maintaining financial stability and continuing its business operations.

Nevertheless, shareholders' freedom to decide whether to distribute dividends should not be interpreted as unlimited discretion. Such discretion remains subject to the principles of good faith, equality and the prohibition of abuse of rights.

A refusal by majority shareholders to distribute dividends does not, in itself, constitute unlawful conduct.

The reinvestment of profits may be justified by the legitimate interests of the company, including the implementation of new projects, business expansion, the fulfilment of financial obligations or the reduction of economic risks.

A different legal assessment is required, however, where the refusal to distribute profits is not supported by genuine economic needs and a prolonged practice of withholding dividends substantially restricts the interests of a minority shareholder.

For example, where a company has consistently generated profits for three or more years, possesses sufficient financial resources and has no obligations that would prevent dividend distribution, yet the majority shareholders repeatedly refuse to approve dividends, questions arise concerning the good faith and justification of those decisions.

Furthermore, establishing an abuse of authority by the majority does not necessarily require proof that the majority shareholders personally derive financial benefits from the company.

The purpose of the decision itself, its economic justification and its impact on the rights of the minority shareholder may all be relevant to the legal assessment.

Accordingly, the principle of majority rule must be balanced against the requirement to protect shareholders' rights.

Otherwise, minority shareholding may become merely formal, leaving the shareholder without a genuine opportunity to obtain economic returns on their investment.

Of particular importance in the context of dividend distribution is the judgment of the Supreme Court of Georgia of 23 January 2025 in Case No. AS-1546-2023.

In that dispute, a shareholder sought payment of dividends that had not been distributed by the company.

The Court explained that decisions concerning dividend distribution fall within the competence of the general meeting of shareholders and that the mere existence of company profits does not automatically create an obligation to distribute those profits among shareholders.

However, the Supreme Court introduced an important legal qualification: judicial intervention in the discretionary powers of the general meeting is permissible where majority shareholders exercise their authority in bad faith, deliberately disregard the rights of another shareholder or abuse their discretion.

This interpretation is particularly significant for the protection of minority shareholders.

It confirms that decisions of the general meeting are not entirely immune from judicial review and that their legality may be assessed in light of the principles of good faith and the proper exercise of authority.

For a shareholder seeking to protect their rights in the absence of a dividend distribution resolution, it is therefore important not merely to establish that the company has generated profits, but also to identify circumstances demonstrating an improper exercise of authority by the majority shareholders.

In conclusion, the power of majority shareholders in an LLC to determine whether and how company profits should be distributed constitutes an essential element of corporate governance.

However, this power cannot be interpreted as unlimited discretion permitting majority shareholders to disregard the property interests of minority shareholders indefinitely.

Courts may intervene in shareholders' decisions where those decisions involve an abuse of discretionary powers, are made in bad faith and deliberately prejudice the interests of minority shareholders.

Author: Onise Adamia

Back to Articles

Need a consultation?

Describe your situation — we will assess the prospects and propose the next steps.

Appoint a consultation